FORUM POST

Welcome to new The Clink Tank - Winepros' live forum where you can share your thoughts with members and guests of our wine community. Discuss your favourite wines, wineries, special events; be contentious, supportive and cheeky; inform and be informed; stay up to date and, most importantly, have fun.

After you have made your posting to The Clink Tank, see it go live by hitting the 'Refresh' or 'Reload' button in your browser. If you have any questions about using the Forum, please email us.

NB: Keep yourself nice! Winepros reserves the right to remove any post deemed unsavoury, vitriolic or vilifying. Please refer to the terms of use for more information.


Dear Winepros Archive Members,

These forums are now closed. You will shortly be redirected to the new VisitVineyards.com and Winepros Archive forums.

If you are not redirected shortly, please click here http://www.visitvineyards.com/forums/


To access the forum, you will need to use your existing Winepros subscriber username and password to login. Alternatively, follow the simple steps and register as a new member. If you have forgotten your password or encounter any difficulties logging in, please click here - to have your password retrieved and emailed to you, or alternatively you can email me directly with any further questions or comments,

Kind Regards,

Andrew Chataway
Webmaster, Winepros Archive.

Post New Message

Search Message Archive

Terms of use

Return to Winepros

Wine storage

Posted by: GB 

Date Posted: Mar 04, 2004, 08:49 PM

Fellow forumnites,
Has anyone had any experience with the Kitchener wine storing cabinets ?
They are apparently designed & produced in Aus for Aus conditions and at half the price of Transtherm ? Complete with Temperature & moisture control.
Any feed back, positive or otherwise ?? Cheers .. GL

 

> Wine storage

Posted by: martinborough 

Date Posted: Mar 04, 2004, 10:10 PM

i have fully checked out these and they are unbeatable for value per bottle.they dont look as good as a transtherm but who cares at less than half the price.be very wary of the noise output on the more expensive models,no such problem with the kitchener.

 

>> Wine storage

Posted by: David 

Date Posted: Mar 05, 2004, 12:21 AM

Hi Martinborough,

Can you tell me Kitchener contact details please?

Thanks in advance
David

 

>>> Wine storage

Posted by: mike1 

Date Posted: Mar 05, 2004, 11:42 AM

Hi David

Kitchener Wine Cabinets
www.kitchenerwinecabinets.com
p: 03 9429 5406
f: 03 9429 2750
a.kitchener@bigpond.com
PO BOx 233,Richmond,Vic 3121

cheers
Mike1

 

>>>> Wine storage

Posted by: JeffB 

Date Posted: Mar 05, 2004, 12:39 PM

Hello GB,
Have had a 250 bottle capacity kitchener for about 2 1/2 years - only moving part (when on) is the fan, unlike several European models that do vibrate. Granted not as attractive as European counterparts and doesn't have the gadgets - but half the price makes it a good buy.I purchased a max/min temperature/humidity gauge for inside the unit. However these readings were of air space inside the unit - bought a tel-tru temperature gauge with a metal probe and siliconed (if there is such a word)it into a wine bottle (full of water) for liquid temperature. Amazing how stable liquid temperature is compared to air temperature.
I highly recommended the Kitchener.

Regards

JeffB

 

>>>>> Wine storage

Posted by: GB 

Date Posted: Mar 05, 2004, 08:18 PM

Thanks JeffB, Martinborough & Mike1,
Your input is very valuable. The 20 case one looks like the way to go. Temp & moisture stable with a minimum of noise seems ideal.
Do they deliver,install,stabilise & guarantee?

 

>>>>>> Wine storage

Posted by: radioactiveman 

Date Posted: Mar 07, 2004, 11:18 PM

GB,

KG252 $2800 plus $250 delivery. They will send you instructions for installation and set up. There are also details of set up on their website. Been looking at one of these for a little while now. I'm even considering the KG410 but that would cost $4350 plus $350 delivery.

If you assume a cabinet life of ten years, the KG252 will cost $1.21 per bottle, per year. Running costs would be additional to this but these are quite economical, I'm told.


Cheers

Jamie

 

>>>> Wine storage

Posted by: David 

Date Posted: Mar 06, 2004, 12:27 AM

Dear Mike,

Thanks for your info. Much appreciated

Regards,
David

 

>> Wine storage

Posted by: cranky 

Date Posted: Mar 06, 2004, 06:17 PM

How do they compare with Vintec?

 

>>> Wine storage

Posted by: martinborough 

Date Posted: Mar 07, 2004, 10:37 AM

vintec,although the most accessable unit on the market(david jones etc.)it is by far the noisiest.i had a client who sent their unit back and bought a transtherm(money not an object).

 

>>>> Wine storage

Posted by: cranky 

Date Posted: Mar 09, 2004, 09:13 PM

Noisy is bad.
It also appears that you get around twice the capacity in a Kitchener for the equivalent cost in a Vintec (which is itself half the price of a Transtherm).
One of the VC's over here has just started offering the latter two brands. The purchase price does count towards Cellar Shares, though. Probably still not incentive enough! ;-)

 

>>>>> Wine storage

Posted by: Claret 

Date Posted: May 23, 2005, 08:12 PM

I have owned a Kitchener 410 for a couple of years and I am delighted with its performance. Reds are just right after 10 minutes out of the unit and whites can be drunk straight from the unit or after perhaps 10 minutes in the fridge. The 410 is massive but it does a great job.

 

> Wine storage

Posted by: Richard 

Date Posted: Oct 14, 2005, 03:17 PM

They are great value

And the company has a great service approach.

They aren't a "furniture piece" like the overpriced glass door European ones, but are very functional

 

>> Wine storage

Posted by: AndrewW 

Date Posted: Dec 13, 2005, 03:21 PM

I'm in Brisbane and have had a 252 bottle unit for around 4 years. I've found that it's not too bad on the whole, but in the height of a Brisbane summer it just doesn't cope properly.

We had temperatures in the mid to high 30s last week and my fluid temperature was up to 19.5 - not really optimal (although certainly better than the ambient 37 degrees!). Kitchener have previously advised that the cabinet must be fully stocked to provide thermal inertia - my cabinet is chock-a-block (sadly many of the bottles are only water!) barring a handful of empty spaces. This behaviour has been consistent since I have had the cabinet; it sits nicely at around 14 degrees except in summer, when it fluctuates between 14 and 20.

In discussions with Kitchener they seemed puzzled by my reports... this year I upgraded my thermometers thinking that perhaps they were off, but the new gear confirms the same findings. I have not yet approached them again for a response, but previous conversations gave me the impression that they would be interested in trying to help even though I am out of warranty.

So... based on my experience, they are good value but do not really provide rock-solid thermal stability in hot conditions.

 

>>> Wine storage

Posted by: Peter 

Date Posted: Jan 08, 2006, 04:26 PM

I'm currently looking at wine cabinets and the 252 Kitchener is definitely on my list. I am concerned about the temperature fluctuations you are talking about though. Is the actual cabinet stored in a 37 degree temperature (for example in a shed) or is that just the weather temperature outside and the cabinet is sitting in a cooler environment? I am achieving temperatures as stable as this in a heavily insulated area in my house with no extra cooling.

Also, has anyone else got any experience with other brands?

 

>>>> Wine storage

Posted by: AndrewW 

Date Posted: Jan 09, 2006, 08:49 AM

The cabinet is stored under the house on a concrete slab - we have a "Queenslander" style house up on stumps, so it is as cool there as you are going to get in ambient conditions. The high ambients are just a damn hot summer.

 

>>>>> Wine storage

Posted by: mattb 

Date Posted: Dec 09, 2007, 10:08 PM

I am starting to look at buying a wine cabinet. I am also in Brisbane. Have you had a satisfactory end to the temp fluctuation?

 

>>>>>> Wine storage

Posted by: AndrewW 

Date Posted: Dec 10, 2007, 09:52 AM

Haven't pursued it any further... life has been too hectic lately to manage anything but the bare essentials! My wine cabinet is well down on the list of priorities :-(

It's been coping OK this summer as we haven't had anything like the many consecutive days of mid to high 30s. The occasional really hot days have been followed by milder temperatures so it has not been a problem so far, and it's sitting around 14-15 degrees.

If I ever get a free weekend (ha ha) I'm considering doing a mod to it myself to install additional peltiers and heatsinks in the air inlets - the theory being that this will pre-cool the air that is cooling the original heatsinks. I just have to figure out where to hook in to get some thermostat-switched current to drive a relay.

 

>>> Wine storage

Posted by: Derek 

Date Posted: Mar 21, 2006, 10:54 AM

Hi Andrew

Have you sorted out your summer liquid temp problem or is it something you have to live with?

Regards
Derek

 

>>>> Wine storage

Posted by: Glenn 

Date Posted: Mar 28, 2006, 09:32 PM

Dereck, Andrew,

Interested in any feedback on the temperature fluctuation issue.

Also wondering if you have any idea of the performance of the Liebherr units?

 

>>>> Wine storage

Posted by: AndrewW 

Date Posted: May 01, 2006, 05:17 PM

Haven't approached Kitchener yet... I've been waiting for the weather to cool since if they offer me any kind of solution it will likely involve a power outage to the cabinet, so I want the ambient temperatures to be nice and low! June should just about do it I reckon.

 

> Wine storage

Posted by: Dan 

Date Posted: Jul 18, 2007, 11:32 PM

I have had a Kitchener KG252 for several years now and has been very efficient and trouble free. I'm looking to downsize as I no longer have the space/need for this size. Send me an email at danads@mac.com for more info.

 

 

Back to Winepros Forum

 

Search Message Archive

Keyword(s)

Messages from last: